The Southern Maryland Grilled Cheese isn’t just a sandwich—it’s a love letter to Chesapeake Bay flavors. Born from the docks of Crisfield and the kitchens of Annapolis, this dish marries the simplicity of comfort food with Maryland’s seafood heritage. Imagine golden sourdough cradling Old Bay-kissed crab meat and melted cheddar, all crisped to perfection in a cast-iron skillet. It’s the kind of meal watermen might pack for a day on the Bay, now elevated to gourmet status at local pubs like The Red Hen in Lexington Park. For Marylanders, it’s nostalgia on a plate; for visitors, a delicious crash course in coastal cuisine.
Core Ingredients
- Bread: Thick-cut sourdough from The Breadery in Sykesville or Baltimore’s Stone Hearth Bakery rye—sturdy enough to hold juicy crab without sogginess.
- Cheese: Sharp cheddar (try Cabot Creamery’s Chesapeake Bay-aged reserve) and creamy American for that iconic pull.
- Old Bay: The state’s unofficial spice, blended into butter for a briny crust.
- Butter: Salted Kerrygold, whipped with Old Bay (1 tsp per ½ stick) for a seasoned sear.
Optional Add-Ins
- Lump crab meat: Fresh Chesapeake blue crab from Jimmy’s Famous Seafood or J.M. Clayton’s canned for convenience.
- Bacon: Thick-cut, applewood-smoked strips from Broom’s Bloom Dairy in Bel Air.
- Caramelized onions: Slow-cooked with a splash of Boordy Vineyards Riesling for sweetness.
Maryland’s culinary identity is steeped in the Bay’s bounty. Old Bay seasoning—a mix of paprika, celery salt, and spices—was invented in Baltimore in 1939, originally for crabs but now a pantry staple. Local cheeses like Firefly Farms’ Merry Goat Round add tangy depth, while Smith Island Baking Company’s sourdough lends a chewy, salt-air crust. Even the crab matters: Blue crabs from the Chesapeake are sweeter than imported varieties, thanks to the Bay’s unique brackish waters.
Essential Tools
A well-seasoned cast-iron skillet (like Lodge’s Maryland flag edition) ensures even heat for that signature crunch. A fish spatula—stolen from your crab feast toolkit—flips sandwiches without tearing. For buttering, repurpose a National Bohemian beer cap as a mini spreader. No gadgets needed; this is blue-collar cooking at its finest.
Read Here : https://flavourfolk.com/the-ultimate-bbq-sauce-on-hamburgers-recipe/
Step-by-Step Instructions
Prep the Butter
Mix softened butter with Old Bay (1 tsp per ½ stick) and a squeeze of lemon juice. Let it rest 10 minutes—the spices bloom, infusing the butter with a smoky-sweet aroma.
Layer the Fillings
Start with cheddar, then layer crab (pat dry to avoid sogginess), a sprinkle of Old Bay, and American cheese. Add bacon or onions between cheeses to lock in moisture.
Grill to Perfection
Heat the skillet on medium-low. Cook 3–4 minutes per side, pressing gently with a bacon press for even browning. The ideal sandwich whispers when pressed—crispy outside, molten inside.
Regional Variations
Crab & Old Bay Grilled Cheese
Fold ¼ cup lump crab into the cheese mix. Add lemon zest and a dash of Old Bay Hot Sauce for heat.
Smith Island-Inspired Grilled Cheese
Add a smear of caramel frosting from Smith Island Cake Company—a nod to Maryland’s official dessert. Sweet-savory magic!
Farmhouse Version
Swap cheddar for Firefly Farms goat cheese and layer with Weaver’s Orchard apple butter. Pair with a Black Ankle Vineyards Chardonnay.
Serving Suggestions
Classic Sides
- Utz Crab Chips: Dusted with Old Bay, these are a salty crunch essential.
- Pickled veggies: Try B’more Organic’s pickled okra or dilly beans.
Coastal Combos
Serve with G&M Restaurant’s crab dip or corn grilled in Old Bay butter.
Beverage Pairings
- Flying Dog Dead Rise: A citrusy ale brewed with Old Bay and orange peel.
- Sweet tea: Spiked with Blackwater Distilling’s Sloop Betty vodka for a Southern twist.
Storing and Reheating
Wrap leftovers in parchment and refrigerate for up to 3 days. Reheat in a skillet with a spritz of water under the lid—steam revives the cheese without sogging the bread. Freeze? Not recommended—crab loses its sweetness.
FAQs
Can I use imitation crab?
Yes, but fresh Chesapeake crab (order online from Cantler’s Riverside Inn) is worth the splurge.
What if I don’t have Old Bay?
Mix ½ tsp paprika, ¼ tsp celery salt, and a pinch of black pepper. Add a smidge of nutmeg for depth.
Dairy-free options?
Use Chao Creamery plant-based cheese and Miyoko’s oat milk butter.
Can I make it ahead for a party?
Prep the crab and cheese mix the night before, but assemble and grill fresh to keep the bread crisp.
Best bread substitutes?
Try jumbo lump crab cake “buns” for a gluten-free, ultra-Maryland twist.
Why This Sandwich Wins?
This isn’t just a meal—it’s a tribute to Maryland’s soul. It’s the sandwich you eat after a day on the Bay, salt in your hair and sun on your skin. Share your creation with #MDGrilledCheese and tag local legends like Faidley’s Seafood for a chance to be featured on their feed. Hungry for more? Hit up Thames Street Oyster House in Baltimore for their crab-stuffed version. Maryland’s heart is in every bite.
